NAS vs Cloud Storage: Which One Is Right for You?

In today’s digital world, data is at the heart of everything we do, from managing business operations to storing family photos and videos. With the amount of data growing exponentially, finding a reliable storage solution is more important than ever.

Two of the most popular storage options are NAS (Network Attached Storage) and Cloud Storage. Both offer secure and efficient ways to store and access data but they differ significantly in ownership, cost, accessibility, and scalability.

If you’re wondering which one fits your needs, this guide breaks it all down from pros and cons to real-world cost comparisons (in NZD) and a look at the best hybrid setup.

What Is NAS (Network Attached Storage)?

Network Attached Storage (NAS) is a dedicated storage device that connects directly to your local network, allowing multiple users to access, share, and back up data easily. Think of it as your private cloud server where you fully control your data without relying on third-party providers.

How NAS Works?

NAS connects to your router or switch, creating a central data hub for your entire network. Whether you’re storing project files, media, or backups, NAS allows instant local access and secure remote access through encrypted applications.

Key Benefits of NAS

1. Complete Data Control and Privacy – All files are stored locally, giving you full control and enhanced security.
2. Fast Local Speeds – Ideal for large media files or multi-user environments where quick data access is essential.
3. One-Time Investment – Avoid recurring monthly fees with an upfront hardware cost.
4. RAID Protection – Built-in redundancy ensures your data stays safe even if a drive fails.
5. Customisation – Can function as a private cloud, backup hub, or even a media streaming server.
6. Remote Accessibility – Tools like Synology Drive or QNAP MyCloud allow secure remote access anytime, anywhere.

NAS is best for small and medium-sized businesses, for creative professionals (designers, photographers, videographers), and users seeking speed, privacy, and long-term savings.

What Is Cloud Storage?

Cloud Storage allows you to store files on remote servers managed by providers like Google Drive, Dropbox, OneDrive, or iCloud. You can upload, sync, and access data from anywhere, all you need is an internet connection.

Key Benefits of Cloud Storage

1. Access Anywhere, Anytime – Access and edit files from any internet-connected device.
2. Instant Scalability – Upgrade your plan as storage needs grow.
3. Automatic Backup and Sync – Keeps files up to date across devices automatically.
4. Disaster-Proof – Data remains safe even if your computer or device is lost.
5. Team Collaboration – Enables real-time sharing and editing for teams.
6. Zero Maintenance – The provider handles all security, storage, and updates.

Cloud storage is best for remote or hybrid teams, businesses prioritising mobility and collaboration, and users seeking automatic syncing and ease of access

NAS vs Cloud Storage: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Cost Comparison (in NZD)

When deciding between NAS and Cloud Storage, cost plays a major role. Here’s how they compare in New Zealand currency:

Cloud Storage Costs (NZD)

For large storage requirements (6TB+), monthly costs can exceed $35–$50 NZD, making it costly long-term.

NAS Storage Costs (NZD)

NAS devices typically last 5 years or more, averaging $200 per year, which is far cheaper long-term than cloud subscriptions for heavy data users.

Example:
A cloud plan costing $20/month = $240/year → $1,200 over 5 years.
NAS setup = ~$1,000 once → significantly more cost-effective beyond year two.

Security and Privacy Considerations

NAS Security

• Data remains on-site — no external access without permission.
• Customisable encryption and password controls.
• Must maintain firmware updates and use secure connections (SSL, VPN).

Cloud Security

• Providers offer end-to-end encryption and multi-factor authentication.
• Risk of data breaches, or provider outages still exists.
• Best to use reputable providers with GDPR and ISO-certified data centers.

Backup and Disaster Recovery

• NAS is ideal for local backups and RAID redundancy. However, without off-site backup, it’s vulnerable to fire or theft.
• Cloud is an excellent for disaster recovery as files are replicated across multiple locations but can be slower for large data restores.

Combining NAS for primary storage with Cloud for backup gives you the speed of NAS and the safety of the Cloud.

Key Challenges

NAS Limitations

• Higher upfront cost
• Requires occasional maintenance
• Vulnerable if remote access isn’t securely configured

Cloud Limitations

• Long-term subscription costs add up
• Dependent on internet connection
• Possible vendor lock-in and privacy limitations

Hybrid Setup: The Best of Both Worlds

A hybrid storage model combines the advantages of both systems:

• Use NAS for high-speed, secure local storage.
• Use Cloud for off-site backup and easy remote access.

This setup delivers speed and control, off-site protection and redundancy and scalability.

Example Hybrid Setup:
Sync your Synology NAS with Google Drive or Dropbox for automated cloud backups of essential data.

Which Should You Choose?

You may choose NAS if you want full control of your data, wants to handle large media files, value one-time costs and works well with sensitive data.

You may consider Cloud if need remote access anywhere, prefers hands-free setup. If you don’t mind paying for monthly subscriptions and require easy collaborations with distributed teams.  

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the NAS vs Cloud Storage debate. Your best choice depends on your workflow, data volume, privacy requirements, and budget.

For most users, a hybrid setup delivers the best balance, keeping sensitive files on a NAS while leveraging the cloud for collaboration and off-site backup.

At IT Hub, we help individuals and businesses choose the most efficient, secure, and scalable storage solutions from Synology NAS setups to Cloud integrations tailored for your needs.

Get in touch today to discover how to protect and optimise your data with the right storage strategy.

Bottom of Form